6 Best Tortilla Warmers of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

The Fox Run Terra Cotta Tortilla Warmer, beautifully made from terracotta, is a versatile and practical tool for every kitchen. It's safe for use in dishwashers, microwaves, and ovens, and it's not just for warming tortillas — you can cook in it too. Although it requires a bit more preparation than other warmers, it significantly outperforms all other types and materials in keeping tortillas warm, reheating effectively, and adding an aesthetic touch to your table setting.

This tortilla warmer needs to be soaked in water for 15 minutes and then heated in a cold oven, but the extra effort is worth it. Once you experience how effectively this terracotta vessel maintains the warmth of tortillas, you'll find other warmers pale in comparison. Not only do tortillas stay warm for over an hour, but the terracotta lid also allows just the right amount of ventilation to prevent sticking and sogginess from condensation. Beyond tortillas, use this versatile warmer to bake eggs or reheat various dishes — it retains heat long after being removed from the oven. We're convinced that terracotta is the superior choice for the future of tortilla warmers!

IMUSA offers tortilla warmers in both soft and hard varieties, and we've tested and highly rated both types. The IMUSA cloth tortilla warmer serves dual purposes: it warms and reheats tortillas, with instructions conveniently printed on the back. It's safe for both the microwave and washing machine, though it should be laid flat to dry. Available in several designs, it caters to a variety of preferences. Priced at $10.78, this warmer is an excellent choice for large dinner parties where multiple warmers might be needed, as well as for those just starting to equip their kitchen and who may not be ready for a solid-state option like the Fox Run Terracotta warmer. As a cloth warmer, it can be stored easily in your linen closet, saving valuable shelf space for other kitchen essentials like a tortilla press.

While Masienda is known primarily as an heirloom masa harina brand looking to shakeup the at-home tortilla making industry, they make beautiful kitchen tools designed for those who value social responsibility and clean aesthetics. Their tortilla pouch, handcrafted from organic cotton and dyes, is meticulously sewn by Oaxacan seamstress Deisy Martinez. At $45 a pop, this warmer is the priciest on our list. However, when you consider that Masienda sources their products responsibly and emphasizes using organic materials, its ecological footprint is much smaller when compared to warmers made from synthetic materials like polyester and plastic, which are derived from non-renewable fossil fuels.

Masienda tortilla warmers come in four different colors and effectively keep tortillas warm for an initial serving. Their breathable cotton construction ensures that tortillas don't become soggy over time. It's important to note that because these warmers are made from woven cotton, they must be hand-washed and laid flat to dry.

Surprisingly, the most adaptable tortilla warmer we found is a simple dish towel, specifically one from Hedley + Bennett. In our quest for the most readily available option, we tested a dishtowel, a common makeshift solution in many kitchens. Dishtowels are convenient, machine-washable, and excellent for a casual weeknight meal. We were particularly impressed with the Hedley + Bennett dishtowels for their range of attractive two-tone colors, their durability, and the fact that you get three for $30.

While not the best at retaining heat, these dishtowels managed to keep tortillas warm for about 15 minutes — perfectly sufficient for a quick breakfast taco. They're also ideal for those looking to avoid cluttering their kitchen with specialized gadgets (like a banana slicer!), offering a simple, no-fuss solution.

The IMUSA Tortilla & Arepa Warmer, a common fixture in many Mexican restaurants, is ideal for busy kitchens that often rely on the microwave to reheat tortillas. However, it's crucial to note that while the base of the warmer is microwave safe, the lid is not and should be removed during reheating.

Valued for its stackable design, dishwasher compatibility, and cost-effectiveness, this all-in-one solution is practical for everyday use. Although it promises to keep tortillas warm for up to an hour, our findings suggest a more realistic 30 minutes of warmth retention, though its closed shell design notably minimized condensation during reheating compared to other hardshell models. Priced at an affordable $14.66, this warmer is a smart pick for high-volume, straightforward kitchens that value efficiency and a touch of traditional charm.

The Dexas Microwavable Tortilla Warmer stands out as the only completely dishwasher and microwave-safe model we tested, making it an exceptionally convenient choice for any kitchen. Proudly made in Texas, USA, which inspired its name, Dexas warmers are designed with a stackable, soft silicone construction. This feature is especially beneficial in kitchens frequented by children, as it reduces the risk of breakage if knocked off the table. Priced at just $9.99, it's the most affordable option, encouraging multiple purchases for various uses beyond just warming and reheating tortillas. While it maintained tortilla warmth for approximately 40 minutes, the snug silicone lid tended to trap moisture, occasionally resulting in a slightly soggy top tortilla. However, this feature could be advantageous for other purposes, like reviving dry leftovers or perfectly reheating rice by retaining essential moisture.