Scroll For More Photos
Finale: The Top Two
Teams Buttercream Beasts and Frosted Freakshow had two challlenges left before one would ultimately be named the winning Halloween warriors.
Step inside the competition for a look at the spookiest creations.
Teams Buttercream Beasts and Frosted Freakshow had two challlenges left before one would ultimately be named the winning Halloween warriors.
More photos after this Ad
Buttercream Beasts worked together in the final Small Scare round to depict what would happen if someone’s hands turned against them.
More photos after this Ad
Frosted Freakshow created a foodie whose hands turned against him and fed him his own brains. This piece earned them their third Small Scare victory as well as first pick of the pumpkin in the final round.
More photos after this Ad
James of the Frosted Freakshows got first pick of the big pumpkins that were brought out specially for this final battle. He ended up choosing the same pumpkin that the Buttercream Beasts wanted... but that didn’t stop him from getting to work.
More photos after this Ad
Scary Tales were on the menu for the final Spine Chiller Challenge. Buttercream Beasts put a dark spin on Goldie Locks and the Three Bears with their creation of Ghouldielocks. She's ready to kill Baby Bear, after she mounted Mama Bear and skinned Papa Bear.
More photos after this Ad
For their Scary Tales display, the Frosted Freakshows made Thumbelina an evil queen who tortured all those creatures who tried to wed her. James put his giant pumpkin to use as the flower from which she rose.
More photos after this Ad
Team Frosted Freakshow hugged as they were announced the winners of Season 9 and took home the grand prize of $50,000.
More photos after this Ad
Jonathan kicked off this week’s Small Scare with a costume that exemplified the classic vampire look. However, the teams were challenged to re-vamp the character into something new but still thirsty for blood.
More photos after this Ad
Todd Tucker and Shinmin Li discuss the amazing displays with the guest judge, Twilight’s Jackson Rathbone.
More photos after this Ad
Team Trio of Terror pulled out their first win of the season with this hip-hop vampire sporting sugar sunglasses and a sugar gold chain that lets everyone know his favorite blood type.
More photos after this Ad
The Spine Chiller Challenge tasked the teams to create a display featuring other holiday mascots enjoying a Halloween night out. Tator and Trio of Terror suspended a pumpkin and cereal treat Jack Frost in the air over a slide made completely of sugar.
More photos after this Ad
James made on an extremely detailed and impressive pumpkin Krampus, who, despite his typical punishing demon character, just wants a night of Halloween fun.
More photos after this Ad
Buttercream Beasts took home yet another win — their third in a row! Their gigantic clown Santa and minion elves feasting on all the Halloween candy brought their story to life.
More photos after this Ad
Beth of Buttercream Beasts is working on covering the pumpkin scallop in fondant for this week's Small Scare Challenge. Imagine what would happen if your dinner came to life and started eating you instead!
More photos after this Ad
Team Burned at the Cake brought an angry pumpkin to life and it's getting its revenge by enjoying a thick slice of human pie. YIKES!
More photos after this Ad
The Frosted Freakshows took home their second Small Scare win in a row with this killer burger made from pumpkin, fondant, rice cereal treats and pulled sugar. He feasts on anyone who tries to feast on him.
More photos after this Ad
Come Round 2, Frosted Freakshow had James making lots and lots of potato bees for their swarm-inspired Spine Chiller display.
More photos after this Ad
Team Trio of Terror decided to make a swarm of crows attacking a man who wanted to take a stroll through the park. Tator carved a fully functioning, life-sized three-tiered water fountain out of pumpkin.
More photos after this Ad
This week marked the second one in a row that Team Buttercream Beasts won the Spine Chiller challenge. The judges appreciated their swarm of killer potato bunnies, which featured a leader made from a combo of rice cereal treats and cake. Beth used her hands to paint on the buttercream, which gives the bunny a furlike finish.
More photos after this Ad
In Week 1, Angela, who was the original sugar artist on Team Buttercream Beasts, left the competition after the Small Scare Challenge and didn't return. Luckily for the team, though, sugar artist Rebecca from the fallen team, Hangry Haunters, volunteered to help get them back in the game.
More photos after this Ad
Trio of Terror celebrated after finishing this week’s Small Scare Challenge: combine cake, sugar and pumpkin to create an exhibit from a haunted museum that came to life.
More photos after this Ad
Frosted Freakshow won this one with their mummified T-rex who’s ready to trick-or-treat. The judges loved the costumed creature and were impressed with the detail James put into the sweet potato head.
More photos after this Ad
Buttercream Beasts wowed the judges with their take on the zombie dating show spine chiller. Beth hung life-size cake and cereal treat zombie body pieces to pull out a win.
More photos after this Ad
In the Spince Chiller, each teams provided a tasting element that pleased the judges, but for Trio of Terror, it was the make-or-break element of their display. Froggie’s green tea cheesecake saved them and sent Malicious Mavens to the graveyard.
More photos after this Ad
Jonathan and the five teams take a huge group selfie in front of the Spine Chiller displays as week 2 comes to a close.
More photos after this Ad
Look who visited the judges’ table this week! None other than Elvira, Mistress of the Dark, joined returning favorites Todd Tucker and Shinmin Li.
More photos after this Ad
In a small scare called The Stuffed Animals’ Evil Twin, Team Malicious Mavens won with their dark and scary opposite of a cute and cuddly bedtime pal. This devil teddy, made of pumpkin and rice cereal treats, has a hypno-wheel made of sugar.
More photos after this Ad
Right out of the gate, the judges were impressed with Julian’s sugar work for Team Burned at the Cake’s small scare. Shinmin Li said he “pulled it exactly at the right temperature” to create a beautiful yet creepy demon tongue.
More photos after this Ad
This challenge was to create a display about a nightmare you couldn’t wake up from. For Beth and Matt, that nightmare was their sugar artist, Angela becoming too sick to continue on in the challenge. The Buttercream Beasts were left to complete their demon filled swamp without their third member.
More photos after this Ad
Team Trio of Terror’s pumpkin carver, Tator, watches as their cake artist, Kristen, forms the face for their boy whose nightmare is a bed full of spiders.
More photos after this Ad
Team Burned at the Cake took home the first spine chiller win of the season. Their never-ending nightmare featured a little girl who, when she sought comfort in her mother after a demon filled nightmare, was terrified to find out that the mother was really the demon all along.
More photos after this Ad